Victorian on West 21 St.
sent May 5, 2006
Dear Editor:
Rubye Jenkins-Husband, at a recent caucus meeting about unchecked demolitions, noted that the continued existence of the Dickson Tavern, in its original location, is a huge factor in its historic legitimacy. The Victorian home at 130 West 21st Street is a part of a noteworthy neighborhood that runs west to the Erie Cemetery. Moving this structure would diminish its "worth" and the value of the other buildings in this National Trust West 21st Street Historical District.
Erie schools Superintendent Jim Barker claims a need for employee parking, yet, according to your story on May 4, he already rents out spaces "in a nearby lot." Getting rid of this building is about generating income.
Barker's offer to give the away the building with a $10,000 dollar stipend is a public relations stunt. Demolition costs are at least double that amount; moving costs are even higher. Your paper's survey asked what should be done with the building; but offered only two Barker-approved answers: move or demolish.
A few months ago, the Erie County Historical Society was roundly criticized for its sale of Native American artifacts, but, their relocation didn't lessen their value. Both of Jim Barker's "options" diminish both the home and the neighborhood. A good steward would transfer the building and property to someone who will care for this century-old gem.
Sincerely,
CIVITAS
Rubye Jenkins-Husband, at a recent caucus meeting about unchecked demolitions, noted that the continued existence of the Dickson Tavern, in its original location, is a huge factor in its historic legitimacy. The Victorian home at 130 West 21st Street is a part of a noteworthy neighborhood that runs west to the Erie Cemetery. Moving this structure would diminish its "worth" and the value of the other buildings in this National Trust West 21st Street Historical District.
Erie schools Superintendent Jim Barker claims a need for employee parking, yet, according to your story on May 4, he already rents out spaces "in a nearby lot." Getting rid of this building is about generating income.
Barker's offer to give the away the building with a $10,000 dollar stipend is a public relations stunt. Demolition costs are at least double that amount; moving costs are even higher. Your paper's survey asked what should be done with the building; but offered only two Barker-approved answers: move or demolish.
A few months ago, the Erie County Historical Society was roundly criticized for its sale of Native American artifacts, but, their relocation didn't lessen their value. Both of Jim Barker's "options" diminish both the home and the neighborhood. A good steward would transfer the building and property to someone who will care for this century-old gem.
Sincerely,
CIVITAS
